MOTHER CARBON

MOTHER InsightsLetters

MOTHER Letters ·

Rated Before Issued

A community biochar project in Western India has been graded before issuing a single credit. The grade speaks to likelihood; the tonnes themselves are yet to be made.

Dusk over harvested fields in Western India. Farmers stand beside a row of open cone kilns with smoke rising and bundles of crop residue on the ground. Faint, half-transparent units rise along a dashed arc from the kilns, standing for credits not yet issued.

The record

On 13 November, Varaha announced that its Agnisparsh biochar project in Western India carries an ex ante rating of A.pre from BeZero Carbon, assigned in October with low execution risk.1,2 The suffix marks a grade given before issuance; A.pre stands third on an eight-point scale.3

Some 450 Kon-Tiki kilns turn crop residues, otherwise burned after harvest, into biochar returned to farmers without charge. First issuance is planned for January 2027, with more than 100,000 tonnes expected that year.1

BeZero's eight-point ex ante scale from highest to lowest likelihood: AAA, AA, A, BBB, BB, B, C and D, each with the suffix .pre. Agnisparsh is rated A.pre, the third grade, with low project execution risk.
Figure 1. Third of eight grades. Where the rating sits on BeZero’s ex ante scale. Source: BeZero Carbon (n.d.); Varaha (2026).

Our read

The grade weighs additionality, carbon accounting and permanence before a tonne exists.2 Its value lies in timing: buyers and lenders gain an independent view of delivery risk when finance is committed, before a registry has anything to record.

Its limits deserve equal candour: no credit issued, a methodology still under assessment, no buyer named.1

A grade is a considered opinion about a tonne not yet made. January’s issuance will offer the first evidence against which to read it.

Timeline. Done: March 2026, Rainbow confirmed eligible for the Core Carbon Principles; October 2026, A.pre rating assigned; 13 November 2026, rating announced. Still to come: review of the methodology for the Core Carbon Principles; January 2027, first issuance planned; 2027, more than 100,000 tonnes to deliver. No credits issued as of 13 November 2026.
Figure 2. From rating to first credits. Schematic: the record so far, and what is still to come. Source: Varaha (2026); Carbon Herald (2026).

Room for disagreement

Quality in smallholder biochar, dispersed across farms, has long been hard to show. A grade before issuance offers such projects a common measure, and the Rainbow programme was confirmed eligible for the Core Carbon Principles in March.1

What to watch

January 2027
First issuance. The first verified credits.1
Pending
Methodology review. The assessment of Rainbow’s open-kiln methodology.1
2027
Delivery. Whether volumes approach the 100,000 tonnes expected.1

Also worth your time

The Antalya Statement. Zambia signed the Antalya Statement on Mobilising Private Finance for Climate Action on 12 November and joined the launch of a playbook on high-integrity credits.

Perspectives No. 003. Our essay on the claims gathering around a tonne before issuance.


For the farmers tending these kilns, the work has begun; we will read January’s issuance against the grade that preceded it.

The same fields in morning light. The kilns are cold, the farmers stand beside them, and the sun is up over the hills.

Foster the world that fostered you.

Subscribe to MOTHER Insights

MOTHER Carbon. Fostering Earth.

The Earth raised us. Now it is our turn.

MOTHER takes no view on any country, project or crediting programme named in this letter. This letter reports what the public record discloses and makes no claim about the integrity of any credit.