MOTHER CARBON

MOTHER InsightsLetters

MOTHER Letters ·

Is it safe here?

Every child asks it. A number cannot answer it alone.

A small child stands at a dark window with one hand raised to the glass, rain falling over the roofs outside. A lamp burns beside the window.

Dear one,

Every child asks it, in the dark, when the rain comes hard against the window and the house seems suddenly small. Is it safe here?

I have listened to that question for as long as there have been children and rain. I have answered it with a lamp left burning, with a voice from the next room. I have never once answered it with a number.

And yet in Oldsmar, Florida, a single house now carries two answers. The federal map says minimal hazard. The score on its listing says seven out of ten. The same walls, the same ground, the same rain on its way.

One house divided down the middle. On the left, a federal map: FEMA Zone X, minimal hazard. On the right, rain and rising water: the score on the listing, 7 out of 10, 74 to 82 percent over 30 years.
Source: Florida complaint, para 107 to 108. The two systems measure different things, so they are not like for like.

The waters are rising, fear rises with them, and a number is something to hold in the dark.

Last month those answers came before a court. Florida’s attorney general has sued First Street Technology, the firm behind the score, saying its numbers deceive. First Street says federal maps read a whole community, while it reads each home. No judge has ruled, and a mother hears both children before she speaks.

But I will not stay quiet

Set two flood models side by side in Los Angeles, and the chance they agree on which properties stand at risk is about one in four. Both may be honest. The future is a country no one has visited, and you deserve to be told so.

Pictogram of 100 houses with 24 filled: about 24 in every 100, the chance two flood models agree on which Los Angeles properties are at risk. Below, other models and places: New York City coastal flood 21 percent, California fire 12 percent.
Los Angeles: First Street and PRIMo-Drain, county-scale agreement index, Earth’s Future, 2024, on an older First Street model. New York (90 schools) and California (128 post offices): Jupiter and XDI, CarbonPlan review, via Bloomberg, 2024. Different studies and measures, so read each alone. Agreement does not show accuracy.

And already the number moves through people’s lives. Perhaps they saw real danger. Perhaps they saw only a number.

Bar chart of homes listed in June 2024 that sold, by flood score: low risk, scored 1 or 2, 71 percent; high risk, scored 9 or 10, 52 percent.
Source: Zillow Research, March 2025, cited in the Florida complaint. A correlation, which does not show the score caused the difference, and some of these sales may have closed later.

So stand up and ask

Ask what was measured.

Ask what was modelled.

Ask what is still only a promise.

Ask every company and every government that tells you the future is in hand. Love has never been afraid of a hard question.

A stream gauge and a solid line, labelled Measured. The line breaks into a fan of dotted forecasts, labelled Modelled. They end at a sign reading 7, labelled Still a promise.

Do not be frightened into silence, and do not be soothed into it. Walk your street after the rain. Learn where the water goes. Knock on your neighbour’s door, for no one was ever kept safe alone.

One day someone small will stand beside you at the window and ask if it is safe here. May you have an honest answer, and a steady hand to give it with.

The same window at dawn. The rain has stopped. An adult and a child stand hand in hand, looking out at the rising sun over the roofs.

Stand with me

MOTHER Insights is where we keep asking, together. Subscribe, and bring someone you love.

Foster the world that fostered you.

Subscribe to MOTHER Insights

MOTHER Carbon. Fostering Earth.

The Earth raised us. Now it is our turn.

MOTHER Carbon takes no view on this case or on any company named. These are allegations and no court has ruled. MOTHER Carbon does not provide, arrange or recommend financing.