MOTHER CARBON

MOTHER InsightsLetters

MOTHER Letters ·

The bus that never ran

A verifier says every tonne is real. UN reviewers say the paperwork does not yet show how.

Dusk on a Bangkok street lined with shophouses and palms. A cream electric bus drives towards a bus stop where three people wait. Behind it, drawn only in dashed white outline with a puff of exhaust, is the diesel bus that never ran.

Switzerland counts the carbon saved by electric buses in Bangkok towards its climate target. A verifier says every tonne is real. UN reviewers say the paperwork does not yet show how.

Every day, electric buses run scheduled public routes across Bangkok. They are operated by Energy Absolute, and each year the carbon dioxide they are calculated to save is sold abroad.

The buyer is the KliK Foundation, which uses the tonnes to meet an obligation under Swiss law. Switzerland then counts them towards its own target under the Paris Agreement.

In September, KliK announced the latest batch, and the announcement was certain. A third party had verified the monitoring report, “confirming that all emission reductions are real”.

The UN had already looked at the same buses, and given a more careful answer.

Two answers

Under Article 6.2 of the Paris Agreement, each country in a trade must report how the trade works, and a team of UN experts checks the report. Of Switzerland’s report on the Bangkok buses, the reviewers wrote that it was “not found to be sufficiently transparent or complete in relation to how the cooperative approach ensures that there is no net increase in global emissions”.

They said the same of how its baseline is set. Thailand’s report, on the same buses, was flagged on the same two points.

One bus, two answers. On the left, the buyer, citing a verifier: All emission reductions are real. KliK Foundation, September 2026. On the right, the UN reviewers: Not sufficiently transparent or complete, on how the trade ensures no net increase in global emissions, May 2025.
Sources: KliK Foundation, 8 September 2026; UN review of Switzerland’s initial report, addendum, FCCC/A6/IRTERR.1/2024/CHE/Add.1, 13 May 2025. The two check different things, so they are not like for like.

Both may be honest. The verifier checked a monitoring report. The UN checked what Switzerland put on paper. Neither, on its own, tells you how many tonnes the air was spared.

Where the tonnes come from

A tonne saved is the difference between two cities: the one where the electric buses ran, and one where they did not. Nobody can visit the second. It has to be modelled.

In that unseen city, Switzerland told the reviewers, new routes are served by diesel buses and old buses are replaced with more of the same. Some of today’s passengers would have driven instead. Each year a fixed factor of 0.99 is applied to the imagined fleet, because “no country-specific data exist”.

Two cities. The city that ran: electric buses on the route, with distance driven monitored. The city that never ran: diesel buses on the same routes, modelled; some riders would have driven, modelled. The gap between the two is what gets sold as tonnes.
Source: UN review of Switzerland’s initial report, addendum, table 3, cooperative approach CA0003. The baseline draws on Thai methodologies T-VER-METH-TM-05 and TM-06.

The distance a bus drives can be measured. A bus that never ran cannot.

What happens now

Switzerland welcomed the findings and said it “will update its initial report”. Bangkok is one trade among many. Across all the reviews published so far, the UN counted 543 inconsistencies.

So stand up and ask

Ask what was measured.

Ask what was modelled.

Ask what is still only a promise.

Three icons. A dial, labelled Measured: distance the electric buses drove. A dashed bus outline, labelled Modelled: the diesel buses that never ran. A signpost, labelled Still a promise: no net increase in global emissions.

When a government counts a tonne from abroad, ask to see both cities: the one that was measured, and the one that was modelled. Then ask who checked each.

COP31 opens in Antalya on 9 November. It is a good week to ask.

The buses will keep running. The question is whether the working runs with them.

The same Bangkok street in the morning light. The ghost diesel bus is gone. The electric bus has pulled up at the stop, where three people wait to board.

Keep asking with us

MOTHER Insights follows the tonnes from the street to the ledger, and asks what sits behind each one. Subscribe, and bring someone who would ask the same questions.

Foster the world that fostered you.

Subscribe to MOTHER Insights

MOTHER Carbon. Fostering Earth.

The Earth raised us. Now it is our turn.

MOTHER Carbon takes no view on Energy Absolute, the KliK Foundation, Switzerland, Thailand or the programme. The UN findings concern the information reported, not the tonnes themselves. MOTHER Carbon does not provide, arrange or recommend financing.